Strawberry sits on the eastern side of Highway 101 - a small peninsula jutting into Richardson Bay that operates as its own distinct world despite the technical Mill Valley, CA address. Homes follow a modest ridge of hills, and from up there you get views of the bay, the San Francisco skyline, and Mount Tamalpais all at once. The geography is specific: Strawberry Spit - also known as Sanctuary Island - and Aramburu Island are both within the Richardson Bay embayment, and they give the neighborhood a sense of place you don't find in most suburban pockets this close to the freeway. It easily stands out as one of the best neighborhoods in Mill Valley, CA.
If you're shopping here, be ready. The broader Mill Valley market shows a median sale price of roughly $3.22 million, homes are sitting on the market an average of nine days, and supply sits at about 1.2 months. That combination doesn't leave a lot of room for hesitation.
Local Real Estate and Home Prices
About 94% of homes across Mill Valley are selling above list price - which tells you something about how prepared buyers need to be before they make a move. The city-wide median of $3.22 million is the headline number, but within Strawberry specifically, average home values have historically landed between $2.26 million and $2.29 million. That's the peninsula proper.
Pull over one sub-area and you get a slightly different picture. Strawberry Manor has been tracking closer to a $1.98 million median sale price. The housing stock throughout is largely hillside single-family homes and waterfront properties - both built to make the most of where they sit on Richardson Bay.
Housing Types and Availability
Most of what you'll find here are established single-family homes, many elevated on the ridge to take advantage of bay sightlines. Inventory is genuinely thin. Recent data shows just 18 homes sold across the broader Mill Valley market in a single month, with only 21 active listings citywide at the time. When something new comes on, it moves. Monitor the listings.
Daily Life, Dining, and Retail
Strawberry Village is the commercial anchor - an open-air shopping center built in 1964 in a Town & Country style that draws from Mill Valley, Tiburon, Belvedere, and Sausalito. For day-to-day life, it handles the basics: groceries, errands, local services, all without getting on the highway.
It's also where most of the dining happens for the peninsula.
Neighborhood Restaurants
Inside and around Strawberry Village you'll find Pizza Antica, Harmony Restaurant, and Cholita Linda. Nearby, Troya Mediterranean Tiburon, Tartine, and Via Piccola Trattoria round out the sit-down options.
For something more casual, West Coast Sourdough, High Tech Burrito, and Hook Fish at Proof Lab Beer Garden are the go-to spots. Tam Tavern, Notte Divino, Piatti, Thep Lela Thai Restaurant, and ALOH-O Sushi fill out the rest of the regular rotation.
Public Schools and Local Climate
Strawberry shares Mill Valley's mild year-round climate - temperatures that generally run between 43°F and 73°F, rarely dipping below 36°F. Summers are long, comfortable, and mostly clear. Winters are shorter, colder, and wetter, but not dramatically so.
The peninsula position offers a slight buffer from the heavy fog that rolls through other parts of the Bay Area, which means the Richardson Bay shoreline stays usable for most of the year - not just on the days when everything lines up perfectly.
School District Zoning
The neighborhood falls within the Mill Valley Elementary School District. Strawberry Point Elementary School is the public campus located directly in the community - one of five elementary schools operating within the district. That's your starting point for school research here.
Short-Term Rental Rules for Property Owners
Mill Valley allows short-term rentals in most residential units. The city defines them as any dwelling rented for overnight lodging for less than 30 consecutive days. The exception: deed-restricted Accessory Dwelling Units and Junior Accessory Dwelling Units are off-limits for short-term rental use. If you're buying with rental income in mind, that distinction matters.
You'll need formal city approval before you list anything. There's also an annual renewal process to stay in compliance - it's not a one-time filing.
Permits and Taxes
Before listing, owners need both a Residential Short-Term Rental Permit and a Residential Business License. Registration with the city is required, along with a registration fee and the business license fee. On top of that, you're responsible for collecting and remitting a transient occupancy tax on all short-term stays.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are typical home prices in the Strawberry neighborhood of Mill Valley, CA?
Home values in the Strawberry area generally run between $2.26 million and $2.29 million. Strawberry Manor, a sub-area within the neighborhood, has been tracking closer to a $1.98 million median. The broader Mill Valley market median sits at roughly $3.22 million.
Which Mill Valley public schools serve the Strawberry community?
Strawberry falls within the Mill Valley Elementary School District. Most local kids attend Strawberry Point Elementary School, which is one of five elementary campuses in the district.
What is the weather like in Strawberry, Mill Valley?
Generally sunny and mild - long comfortable summers, shorter and wetter winters. Temperatures year-round tend to stay between 43°F and 73°F and rarely fall below 36°F.
What are the main dining options in Strawberry?
Strawberry Village is the center of it. You'll find Pizza Antica, Harmony Restaurant, and Cholita Linda there, along with nearby spots like Tartine, Troya Mediterranean Tiburon, and Hook Fish at Proof Lab Beer Garden.